Subscribe for CLE Announcements

PPE Logo
For Live and Recorded CLE Seminars, click:
Blog speechadvise

Case Summary

4906 In a college instructor's action against his former employer for disability discrimination, the employer satisfied its burden on summary judgment by proffering as legitimate reasons for reducing the plaintiff's teaching load the school's declining admissions, and plaintiff's failure to enroll in a graduate degree program as required by defendant's policy and that of the accrediting agency; this shifted to plaintiff the burden of showing those reasons were not legitimate; it was found that plaintiff failed to meet this burden, because although plaintiff claimed the reduction in his teaching assignments resulted from his status as HIV positive, he was unable to show that anyone involved in the adverse employment action knew of that status; it was found that an accommodation offered by the employer for plaintiff's unspecified health problem was reasonable; whether the employer engaged in a timely, good faith, interactive process to find a reasonable accommodation was irrelevant, because plaintiff was unable to show a reasonable accommodation other than that offered by the employer that could have been made as the result of such a process; plaintiff's inability to establish his claim of discrimination was fatal to his action for failure to maintain a discrimination-free work environment; plaintiff's resignation did not constitute a constructive termination, because a reasonable employer under the circumstances would not have known that reducing plaintiff's course load would require a reasonable person in plaintiff's position to resign.

Citation

SCOTCH v ART INSTITUTE OF CA (Reduced Course Load) 173 CA4 986 [See: GovC 12900 etseq; Knight v Hayward USD 132 CA4 121, T/AT 9/05; Wilson v County 169 CA4 1185, T/AT 2/09]

2009 Case Summaries


JAN: 4802 | 4803 | 4804 | 4805 | 4806 | 4807 | 4808 | 4809 | 4810 | 4811 | 4812 | 4813 | 4814 | 4815 | 4816 | 4817 | 4818 | 4819 | 4820 | 4821 | 4822 | p1469 | p1470 | p1471 | p1472 | p1473 | p1474 | p1475 | p1476 | p1477 | p1478 | p1479 | p1480 | p1481 | p1482 | p1483 | p1484 | p1485 | p1486 | p1487 | p1488 | p1489 | p1490 | p1491 | p1492 | p1493 | p1494 | p1495 | p1496 | p1497 | p1498 | p1499 | p1500 |
FEB: 4823 | 4824 | 4825 | 4826 | 4827 | 4828 | 4829 | 4830 | 4831 | 4832 | 4833 | 4834 | 4835 | 4836 | 4837 | 4838 | 4839 | 4840 | 4841 | 4842 | 4843 | 4844 | 4845 | 4846 | 4847 | 4848 |
MAR: 4849 | 4850 | 4851 | 4852 | 4853 | 4854 | 4855 | 4856 | 4857 | 4859 | 4860 | 4861 | 4862 | 4863 | p1501 | p1502 | p1503 | p1504 | p1505 | p1506 | p1507 | p1508 | p1509 | p1510 | p1511 | p1512 | p1513 | p1514 | p1515 | p1516 | p1517 | p1518 | p1519 | p1520 | p1521 | p1522 | p1523 | p1524 | p1525 | p1526 | p1527 | p1528 | p1529 | p1530 | p1531 |
APR: 4864 | 4865 | 4866 | 4867 | 4868 | 4869 | 4870 | 4871 | 4872 | 4873 | 4874 | 4875 | 4876 | 4877 | 4878 | 4879 | 4880 | 4881 | 4882 |
MAY: 4883 | 4884 | 4885 | 4886 | 4887 | 4888 | 4889 | 4890 | 4891 | 4892 | 4893 | 4894 | 4895 | 4896 | 4897 | 4898 | p1532 | p1533 | p1534 | p1535 | p1536 | p1537 | p1538 | p1539 | p1540 | p1541 | p1542 | p1543 | p1544 | p1545 | p1546 | p1547 | p1548 | p1549 | p1550 | p1551 | p1552 | p1553 | p1554 | p1555 | p1556 | p1557 | p1558 | p1559 | p1560 | p1561 | p1562 | p1563 | p1564 | p1565 | p1566 |
JUN: 4899 | 4900 | 4901 | 4902 | 4903 | 4904 | 4905 | 4906 | 4907 | 4908 | 4909 | 4910 |
JUL: 4911 | 4912 | 4913 | 4914 | 4915 | 4916 | 4917 | 4918 | 4919 | 4920 | 4921 | 4922 | 4923 | 4924 | 4925 | 4926 | 4927 | 4928 | p1567 | p1568 | p1569 | p1570 | p1571 | p1572 | p1573 | p1574 | p1575 | p1576 | p1577 | p1578 | p1579 |
AUG: 4929 | 4930 | 4931 | 4932 | 4933 | 4934 |
SEP: 4935 | 4936 | 4937 | 4938 | 4939 | 4940 | 4941 | p1580 | p1581 | P1582 | p1583 | p1584 | p1585 | p1586 | p1587 | p1588 | p1589 | p1590 | p1591 | p1592 | p1593 | p1594 |
OCT: 4942 | 4943 | 4944 | 4945 | 4946 | 4947 | 4948 | 4949 |
NOV: 4950 | 4951 | 4952 | 4953 | 4954 | 4955 | 4956 | 4957 | 4958 | 4959 | p1595 | p1596 | p1597 | p1598 | p1599 | p1600 | p1601 | p1602 | p1603 | p1604 | p1605 |
DEC: 4960 | 4961 | 4962 | 4963 | 4964 | 4965 | 4966 | 4967 | 4968 | 4969 |

Torts Case Summaries

1992 | 1993 | 1994 | 1995 | 1996 | 1997 | 1998 | 1999 | 2000
2001 | 2002 | 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009
2010 |

Civil Procedure Case Summaries

2001 | 2002 | 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009
2010 |


Finz Case Law Summaries (Finz Advance Tapes)
PO Box 1422
Sierra Madre, CA 91025
Phone: (877) 858-3848 or (626) 298-6353
Email: faith@advancecollege.org

Copyright by Pincus Legal Education, Inc. ©1992 - 2022
All rights reserved